Les Mis Movie
Posted 21 December 2012 - 02:00 AM
I will say Hathaway's I Dreamed a Dream continues to sound just excellent.
Posted 21 December 2012 - 09:16 AM
I think its going to be fairly critic proof, its the sort of film that gets non regular cinema goers in.
Posted 21 December 2012 - 11:25 AM
The One Day More clip above just confirms what I already thought. In my view the people who come across best are:
- Samantha (The best by far both singing and acting)
- Anne - Seems really good in the dream a dream clips (although she is not in the One Day more clip)
- and Eddy who sounds pretty good too in all the clips I have seen.
Despite my disappointment in Hugh and Amanda I will still be going to see it as soon as I can once it is released. I think there will be lots of good moments whilst expecting some not so good ones along side them.
Also having seen the brief clip of Helena and Sacha I think their parts could come across pretty well. They seem to have a good interaction and the singing is okay for roles that don't nessecarily need the best singers.
Having said that as a big Queen fan I am still worried about what Sacha will be capable of pulling off as Freddie Mercury in the upcoming Bio-pic.
Posted 21 December 2012 - 11:35 AM
I agree that is one of the poorest written reviews I have read in a long time. No balance at all. I am pretty sure that whoever wrote that already had a set view before they even saw the film. Reviews like this are what put me off taking reviewers opinions seriously a long time ago. In my view it is just shoddy / lazy journalism. The only movie reviewier I put any credence in these days is Mark Kermode. I will still be interested to see what he has to say as his views often align quite closely with what I feel about films once I have got around to seeing them.
The fact the review also fails completely to mention Samantha Barks, who I think from the clips I have seen is likely to be one of the standout people in the film is probably because the reviewer could not find anything bad to say about her performance.
And the reviewers assessment of Les Mis as a musical in general in the last paragraph is completely of the mark.
Posted 21 December 2012 - 12:24 PM
Here is the review from Entertainment Weekly, brutal.
Utter rubbish, that reviewer clearly doesn't like Les Mis as a musical, and I think most people who don't like the musical won't like the film, especially as it's pretty much sung-through.
It really annoys me when reviewers aren't capable of even a bit of unbiased journalism, and write such stupid thing as Russell Crowe has a right to be annoyed about singing Broadway when it's clearly not his thing - never mind that it was his choice to do the movie....
Lazy journalism at its worst!
Posted 21 December 2012 - 05:12 PM
And, after other things move forward into act one , its nearer the end than before, so you wouldn't want two finales that close. Its a pity though because you lose some of your musical wow moments to make the film flow.
Posted 21 December 2012 - 05:19 PM
He might have a point about Javert's clothes. Looking at him I see why the musical avoided putting Javert in Napoleon's hat, and think he would look better with the tall one- even if he can't sound as authoritative as Earl.
Otherwise its one of those stock, don't get it/can't be bothered, reviews that come from people the emotional content sweeps over - or the leftwing pseuds or aetheists or neoliberals who don't like the story because its too religious or too left wing.
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users